Want to have your review featured on our website? Post it on a one of these sites, and email us at

Kalen gave us five stars on Yahoo:

“Decent service , but the food is very good and worth the amount of food you get. Almost always able to take home some food and its cheaper than most Italian places in the area. Their pizza and calzones are definitely the best in town.”

Evan H gave us four stars on Yelp:

“Really great NY Style Pizza! The best pizza near Elon and even better they deliver! Not only do they have great pizza by the slice but their other options, including Stromboli etc., are also delicious!”

John C gave our Carrboro store five stars on Yelp:

“I am a New Yorker and retired here in Chapel Hill. I have eaten just about everywhere in the Chapel Hill, Durham and Carrboro Area and well if you have eaten good NY style pizza you probably haven’t had the opportunity to say “Now Thats Good Pizza”. I too have had my days but Annamaria’s Pizza in Carrboro Plaza has an amazing consistency of having a great fresh Tomato sauce, a real Thin (yet not to thin) pizza crust with a nice even cooked med well done pizza crust. Their Meatballs are real tender and full of flavor. The Staff is a nice bunch of guys always willing to make you happy. This is much more then many local pizzerias have offered and I appreciate being able to make a call, order a pie, and when I get there its fresh, ready and tastes great when I get it home and eat it. I would say if you have tried all the rest, try Annamaria’s , they are the best.”

Ron W gave our Carrboro store four stars on Yelp:

“…Boy was I happy when I found Anna Maria’s because it’s real italian food! They do a very nice NJ style pizza which to me means a bit more cheese and a bit thicker crust than NY style but still damn good. I fell in love with the chicken/veal parmigian which is heavenly. A nice sized sub, with breaded meat, wrapped up in nice marinara sauce and melting cheese, wow! You are missing out if you don’t try that bad-boy. Decor is basic pizzeria style: formica tables, self-serve drinks, some neon signs and a couple of TV’s with ESPN. Staff is very nice, it’s a family run restaurant from NJ. So you can say the place is authentic. They also do some pastas and garlic knots but I could never get past the delicious pizzas and subs. So if you’re in the area, stop by Carrboro Plaza for a bit. Anna Maria’s is a little taste from home if you’re a Jersey boy or girl.”

Nean gave our Graham store five stars on Google, saying simply:

“We love the pizza from here.”

Louis gave our Graham store five stars on Google:

“Anna maria’s… place runs smooth the food is amazing. And uncle Charlie has these boys and gals cooking up a storm. Try the bacon ranch pizza its the best pizza I ever had.”

Tom D gave our Hillsborough store five stars on Yahoo:

“Best pizza in NC you got to get some!!!!! you will love it.”

Limeyfer gave our Hillsborough store four stars on Trip Advisor:

“Located at the top of Churton street near Hwy 70 this is a great family friendly restaurant. Standard stromboli, spaghetti, calzone and pizza fare but done very well. Beer and wine is also available. They can handle larger groups as well (such as baseball teams) but call ahead and warn them. Delivery is also available.”